BREAKING: Synod on Synodality Document Outlines Discussion Questions for October Assembly
The 50-page document was written by a committee of 22 people in April and May and approved by Pope Francis.
In advance of a pivotal October assembly on synodality, a new Vatican document released Tuesday outlines key questions for what now promises to be a wide-ranging discussion on Pope Francis’ vision of a more inclusive, decentralized and “listening” Church.
The highly anticipated text, referred to as the instrumentum laboris or “working tool” for the upcoming 16th Ordinary General Assembly of the Synod of Bishops, signals the beginning of a new phase of the Catholic Church’s multiyear Synod on Synodality. Drawing on listening sessions already conducted worldwide at the diocesan, national and continental level, it covers such hot-button topics as women deacons, priestly celibacy, LGBTQ outreach, and highlights a desire for new institutional bodies to allow for greater participation in decision-making by the “People of God.”
At the same time, some of the questions it frames for discussion allude to possible major changes in how the Church operates around the world, through the embrace of an open-ended “synodal” process that entails ongoing dialogue and discernment. The approach is so different, in fact, the document states, that new formation programs will need to be developed “at all levels of ecclesial life and for all the Baptized,” adding that candidates for ordained ministry “must be trained in a synodal style and mentality.”
The text also outlines a “synodal method” of spirituality focused on listening to the Holy Spirit and “discerning the signs of the times.”
The 50-page document was written by a committee of 22 people in April and May and approved by Pope Francis. The text itself stresses that it is “not a document of the Church’s Magisterium, nor is it the report of a sociological survey,” but instead presents the “priorities that emerged from listening to the People of God” in the global synod process thus far.
The instrumentum laboris will guide the discussions at the nearly-month-long synod assembly at the Vatican in October, which will bring together Catholic bishops, priests, religious and laypeople from around the world to discuss and prepare another document.
The delegates for the October synod assembly have not yet been announced. For the first time, about 21% of the voting delegates in the Synod of Bishops will not be bishops, and 70 delegates will be chosen directly by the pope from among a list of 140 laypeople, priests, consecrated women and deacons selected by the leadership of this year’s continental synod meetings.
The main objective of the first session in October 2023, according to the instrumentum laboris, will be to design a plan of study in a “synodal style” and to indicate who will be involved in those discussions. Discernment will be “completed” in the 2024 session of the synod.
The advisory final document at the end of the process in 2024 will be voted on by synod assembly participants and presented to Pope Francis. The Pope can decide, if he wishes, to adopt the text as a papal document or to write his own at the conclusion of the synod.
Underscoring the possibly far-reaching scope of the assembly’s discussions, the document emphasizes that the reappearance of questions already addressed in past synods “should not be hastily dismissed,” noting that a synodal assembly is “a privileged forum” for discussing those issues again.
It also suggests that people who do not understand or agree with what has been proposed undertake a “synodal journey of effective reception.”
New concerns that require “further reflection on the Deposit of Faith and the living Tradition of the Church” could also come up for discussion, it says.
The Role of Women, Inclusion, Priestly Celibacy
The instrumentum laboris is divided into two sections. The first summarizes insights from the continental assemblies and outlines what a synodal Church is and how it should proceed. The second section is a series of 15 worksheets with questions for discernment.
The worksheets will be used to guide the small-group discussions of the October assembly. The small groups, also called circuli minores, will alternate with plenary sessions where all synod participants are together.
The last part of the October gathering will focus on deciding the Church’s next steps and “the necessary in-depth theological and canonical studies in preparation” for a second assembly in October 2024.
“The Synodal Assembly of October 2023 will be asked to listen deeply to the situations in which the Church lives and carries out its mission,” the document states.
“What it means to walk together gains its missionary urgency when this question is asked in a particular context with real people and situations in mind,” it continues. “What is at stake is the ability to proclaim the Gospel by walking together with the men and women of our time, wherever they are, and practicing the catholicity that emerges from walking together with the Churches that live in conditions of particular suffering.”
Among the priorities outlined in the document is the role of women in the Church. One of the “worksheets” included with the text proposes the following question for discernment: “Most of the Continental Assemblies and the syntheses of several Episcopal Conferences call for the question of women’s inclusion in the diaconate to be considered. Is it possible to envisage this, and in what way?”
The synod document also proposes the following as suggestions for prayer and preparatory reflection: “How can we create spaces where those who feel hurt by the Church and unwelcomed by the community feel recognized, received, free to ask questions and not judged? In the light of the Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, what concrete steps are needed to welcome those who feel excluded from the Church because of their status or sexuality (for example, remarried divorcees, people in polygamous marriages, LGBTQ+ people, etc.)?”
Another question recommended for prayer and reflection refers to the discipline of priestly celibacy. “As some continents propose, could a reflection be opened concerning the discipline on access to the Priesthood for married men, at least in some areas?" the document asks.
The text makes repeated reference to “tensions” that have emerged through the synodal process, but it points to these as a positive and necessary part of discerning the Church’s path.
“We should not be frightened by them, nor attempt at any cost to resolve them, but rather engage in ongoing synodal discernment,” the document says. “Only in this way can these tensions become sources of energy and not lapse into destructive polarizations.”
Authority in the Church
The “exercise of authority in the Church” emerges as a major theme in the instrumentum laboris, with the word “authority” appearing more than 50 times in the text.
“In every age, the exercise of authority and responsibility within the Church is influenced by the prevailing management models and imagery of power in society,” the text observes. “How can we become aware of this and exercise an evangelical discernment of the prevailing practices of exercising authority, in the Church and in society?”
One proposed question for discernment for the Synod of Bishops asks, “what can we learn about the exercise of authority and responsibility from other Churches and ecclesial Communities?"
Another question asks, “How can we deal constructively with cases in which those in authority feel they cannot confirm the conclusions reached by a community discernment process, taking a decision in a different direction? What kind of restitution should that authority offer to those who participated in the process?”
Still another question poses, “What stimuli from indigenous, minority and oppressed cultures can help us to rethink our decision-making processes?”
The text also proposes discerning how the awareness that a synodal Church needs co-responsibility and transparency can “form the basis for the reform of institutions, structures and procedures, so as to strengthen change over time.” In particular, it mentions an expressed desire for “more participatory selection procedures, especially with regard to the selection of Bishops.”
‘Conversation in the Spirit’
The document also devotes a significant amount of space, including a full-page illustration, to the concept of “conversation in the Spirit,” which it calls the “synodal method.”
Conversation in the Spirit, which appears 23 times, is described as a process of personal prayer, listening, sharing, making space for others and the Holy Spirit, and group discernment in an atmosphere of prayer.
“It is not conversation in the Spirit,” the document says, “if there is not a step forward in a precise, often unexpected direction that points to concrete action.”
The instrumentum laboris calls for “formation in this method” for all the baptized and for the formation of “facilitators” who can accompany communities in its practice.
“Formation for conversation in the Spirit is formation to be a synodal Church,” it says.
One question asks if conversation in the Spirit can aid “the renewal of decision-making processes in the Church” and if canon law needs to change to facilitate that process.
The document calls for the renewal of the Church’s seminary curriculum to include a greater focus on “a synodal style and mentality,” as well as changes to the language used in liturgy, preaching, catechesis, sacred art, communication and media.
It emphasizes formation for every Catholic as “the indispensable means to make the synodal way of proceeding a pastoral model for the Church’s life and action.”
“Formation for a more genuinely synodal spirituality is at the heart of the renewal of the Church,” the text says.
Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, who holds one of the key positions in the Synod on Synodality, said in a Vatican News interview in April that discernment in the synod is a “spiritual process.”
“And that is why we have this spiritual conversation, or rather this conversation in the Spirit: It is a way of listening and entering into dialogue, not with an attitude of opposition, in order to reach a common conclusion.”
“It is clear,” Cardinal Hollerich added, “that there is always a need for conversion in this process: Sometimes it is the bishop who must convert; sometimes it is the laity who must also convert."
“Spiritual conversation,” which has been mentioned in other synod-related documents, comes from Ignatian spirituality and is tied to the Spiritual Exercises.
- synod on synodality