Catholic Bishops: Centuries of Religious Freedom at Risk with Virginia Veto

Gov. Terry McAuliffe cited concern for same-sex couples and the interests of business leaders among reasons for rejecting new religious freedom protections.

Virginia State Capitol.
Virginia State Capitol. (photo: Joseph Sohm via www.shutterstock.com.)

RICHMOND, Va. — The Virginia governor’s veto of a religious freedom bill means faith-based groups that support marriage as a union of a man and a woman will not have needed protections, the state’s Catholic bishops have warned.

“The Virginia Catholic Conference is deeply dismayed by the governor’s action,” the conference said March 30. “This veto risks the destruction of Virginia’s long tradition of upholding the religious freedom of faith communities which dates back to [Gov.] Thomas Jefferson.”

The bill would have forbidden the state of Virginia from punishing religious groups that follow their sincerely held beliefs that marriage is the union of a man and a woman. The bill passed the House of Delegates by a vote of 59-38 and the Senate by 21-19.

Virginia’s Catholic Conference said the bill would have ensured “that clergy and religious organizations are not penalized by the government.” The bill would also have protected these individuals and organizations from civil liability.

Democratic Gov. Terry McAuliffe vetoed the bill, explaining his actions on live radio Wednesday. He claimed that signing the bill would be “making Virginia unwelcome to same-sex couples, while artificially engendering a sense of fear and persecution among our religious communities.”

He also cited corporate leaders’ opposition to the bill, stating that it was “bad for business.”

“They don't want headaches coming from the state,” McAuliffe said.

Homosexual activist groups also opposed the bill.

The Catholic conference said that the bill does not apply to businesses, but “simply affirms the right of religious organizations to follow their religious beliefs.” The conference charged that Gov. McAuliffe’s veto “marginalizes religious believers who hold to the timeless truth about marriage.”

The legislation would have preserved “fair access to state resources” for clergy and religious organizations, including charities and schools, the conference said.

“Marriage is the first institution, written in natural law and existing before any government or religion, and is between one man and one woman,” the conference added. “Recognizing and honoring this institution is not discrimination, but counting people’s faith against them most certainly is.”

Sen. Charles Carrico Sr. (R-Grayson) sponsored the bill. He told the Washington Post he believes there will be lawsuits against churches without the legislation.

“I think you see a trend around the country right now to promote homosexual beliefs, and I think you see that trend happening on a wide-scale basis,” he said.

The Virginia legislature could override the veto, but that is considered very unlikely, according to the Associated Press.

Other bills to protect religious freedom have drawn significant opposition in recent years. In Georgia on Monday, Republican Gov. Nathan Deal vetoed another religious freedom protection bill.

In some states and the District of Columbia, new laws and funding decisions have shut down Catholic adoption agencies due to their refusal to place children with same-sex couples. Some Catholic schools have also become the targets of lawsuits from employees fired for violating the morals clause on sexual morality in their employment contracts.

Wealthy funders like the Ford Foundation, the Arcus Foundation and the Evelyn and Walter Haas Jr. Fund have poured millions of dollars into legal groups, law school projects and activist groups to counter religious freedom protections.

Pope Francis presides over the Feb. 11 canonization ceremony of the first female Argentinian saint, María Antonia de San José de Paz, known as “Mama Antula,” in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican.

Canonization of Mama Antula, and National Marriage Week (Feb. 17)

Argentina got its first woman saint last weekend — a lay woman who was a Jesuit missionary. The canonization of Mama Antula brought together Pope Francis and the country’s new president, Javier Milei. Catholic News Agency’s editor-in-chief Ken Oliver brings us the story. Then we turn to National Marriage Week. Although the marriage rate is 60% of what it was in the 1950s, studies show people who are married are happier than those who don’t marry. How do we build strong and happy marriages? Witness to Love founders Mary-Rose and Ryan Verret join us with their insights.