Too Short, Too Structured? Cardinals Reflect on Synodal Consistory
Participants highlight benefits of collegial exchange but question whether the format allows real and effective counsel to reach the Pope.
Participants highlight benefits of collegial exchange but question whether the format allows real and effective counsel to reach the Pope.
VATICAN DIARY: This June’s consistory didn’t culminate in any dramatic or decisive result, but the mere fact that it took place was significant.
The Pope thanked the College of Cardinals for their work during a two-day extraordinary consistory, highlighting their reflections on war, poverty, and social fragmentation.
ANALYSIS: Increased participation and opportunity to submit contributions to the Holy Father are new elements to the meeting, but skepticism endures.
The gathering will function as 'a space for mutual listening, discernment, and shared exploration of certain issue,' Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re said.
ANALYSIS: The extraordinary consistory can include the creation of new cardinals, but it can also be a consistory for discussion.
Cardinals choose evangelization and synodality as key topics, disappointing those who expected the liturgy to be a central theme after recent restrictions on the traditional form of the Roman rite, but the Holy Father later insists the liturgy remains a "very concrete" issue that still needs to be addressed.
Cardinals who spoke to the Register as they entered the consistory all said they welcomed the Pope’s decision to host the two-day meeting.
In practical terms, Father de Blignières proposes the creation of a new Church structure — such as a personal apostolic administration or an ordinariate — similar to a diocese but not tied to a specific territory.
Curial reform, synodality, and liturgy are on the agenda in the first such gathering of Pope Leo XIV’s pontificate
Subscriber Service CenterAlready a subscriber? Renew or manage your subscription or gift subscription.
My AccountSubscribe and SAVE at just $1.25 per issue!Start your Register subscription today.
Subscribe NowGive a Gift SubscriptionBless friends, family or clergy with a gift of the Register.
Order NowOrder Bulk SubscriptionsGet a discount on 6 or more copies sent to your parish, organization or school.
Order NowSign-up for E-NewsletterGet Register Updates sent daily or weeklyto your inbox.
Sign Up