Catholic Bishop: Pope Francis is Deeply Concerned About German Church

German media has reported that Pope Francis told Bishop Algermissen that the “Synodal Way” was too focused on “political questions,” such as the position of women in the Church and priestly celibacy.

Bishop Heinz-Josef Algermissen.
Bishop Heinz-Josef Algermissen. (photo: Courtesy photo / Diocese of Fulda.)

VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis has expressed “dramatic concern” about the Catholic Church in Germany, according to a bishop who met him this week.

Bishop Heinz-Josef Algermissen said that the pope addressed the situation in Germany when he spoke to him after the general audience Oct. 7. 

The former bishop of Fulda, in the west-central German state of Hesse, said that the pope recalled the letter he wrote to German Catholics in June 2019, urging them to focus on evangelization. Pope Francis reportedly complained that his message had been ignored.

The pope issued the letter amid concerns at the Vatican over the German Church’s “Synodal Way,” which is bringing together lay people and bishops to discuss four main topics: the way power is exercised in the Church; sexual morality; the priesthood; and the role of women.

The Vatican intervened after the German bishops said that the process would end with a series of “binding” votes, ruling that the plans were “not ecclesiologically valid.” 

The Fuldaer Zeitung reported that the pope told Bishop Algermissen that the “Synodal Way” was too focused on “political questions,” such as the position of women in the Church and priestly celibacy.

Bishop Algermissen said that the pope urged him “very clearly and expressively” to “make sure that the letter is remembered.” 

The 77-year-old bishop said that everywhere he went he was asked: “What is going on in Germany?” He added that the perception in Rome was that the path being pursued by the German Church “deforms and distorts” the Gospel, reported CNA Deutsch, CNA’s German-language news partner.

Bishop Algermissen’s comments echoed those of Vatican Cardinal Kurt Koch, who said last month that the pope had expressed his concern about the Church in Germany “in personal conversations.”

In a Sept. 22 interview with the magazine Herder Korrespondenz, Cardinal Koch said he believed that the pope backed a recent intervention by the Vatican’s doctrinal office in a debate over intercommunion between Catholics and Protestants in Germany. 

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) wrote Sept. 18 to Bishop Georg Bätzing, president of the German bishops’ conference, saying that a proposal for a “Eucharistic meal fellowship” would harm relations with Orthodox Churches.

Bishop Bätzing insisted that Francis “appreciates” the “Synodal Way” after a private audience with the pope in June. 

“I feel strengthened by the intensive exchange with the Holy Father to continue on the path we have taken. The pope appreciates this project, which he associates closely with the concept of ‘synodality’ which he coined,” he said.

Other German Church leaders have voiced misgivings about the “Synodal Way.” Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki of Cologne said last month that the worst outcome would be if the process “leads to a split and thereby outside of the Church, out of communion with the universal Church.”

Bishop Bätzing downplayed the cardinal’s concerns, insisting that the Church in Germany is “part of the Universal Church and nothing will change that.”

In his letter to German Catholics, the pope spoke of a “growing erosion and deterioration of faith.”

“Every time an ecclesial community has tried to get out of its problems alone, relying solely on its own strengths, methods and intelligence, it has ended up multiplying and nurturing the evils it wanted to overcome,” he wrote.

Pope Francis speaks to journalists during the flight from Budapest to Italy on April 30 after his second visit to Hungary in less than two years.

Pope in Hungary, German Tax on Catholicism (May 6)

One of the top stories at last month was about a web platform that seeks to combat porn addictions. The project took its inspiration from an unlikely source: Blessed Carlo Acutis. Register writer Solène Tadié wrote that story. She joins us now from Rome just days after she followed Pope Francis’ travels to Hungary last weekend. Solène gives us highlights about the unique ways of evangelizing in our culture and the impact of the Holy Father on young and old alike in Hungary. Then we turn to happenings in the Church in another European country, Germany. Jonathan Liedl has more on the situation there, and we examine the question: How does the German tax influence German Catholicism?