Hey, gals, there’s a one-time-only “special” on forgiveness in Madrid this week! Had an abortion? No problem, as they say in Spain. The Pope in Rome has waived your culpability — just this once!!
That is how way too many news stories about World Youth Day read. “Pope dangles ‘fruits of divine grace’ to excommunicated Catholics who admit, during Madrid event, to terminations,” the Guardian tells us.
And then, there are the commentaries in response: full of anger and confusion, only adding to the pain people affected by abortion already know. On Slate’s “XX Factor” blog, where you go to find out “What Women Really Think,” Amanda Marcotte writes: “Oh boy, the Vatican, no doubt patting itself on the back for being so generous to the filthy sluts of the world, has set up a six-day event in Madrid where ladies who’ve had abortions can come and confess in order to escape the automatic excommunication they otherwise would get.” Marcotte expresses her feelings about the Church in a poisonous polemical graphic cocktail of rhetorical rage along the lines of, “There go those money-grubbing misogynist child-rapist priests again.”
And so, women can’t receive forgiveness unless they are in Madrid these few days? A priest has to text his bishop if I walk in and bare my soul about this grave sin I am aching for God’s forgiveness for?
Rest assured: It’s not quite what you have been reading in much of the news coverage.
For WYD Madrid, it is true that 200 confessionals have been set up for a sacramental opportunity for pilgrims.
But this abortion-forgiveness issue is not a one-time only or particularly rare opportunity. As one U.S.-based, Rome-trained priest on his way to Madrid pointed out, the position of those confessors is not all that rare, at least not for Americans. “Such faculties to remove the censure incurred by abortion (when someone has an abortion knowing it is a de facto [latae sententiae] excommunicable offense) are normal in the U.S. Basically every bishop gives it to every priest who hears confessions because abortion is rather common, especially among women who have been away from the sacrament for awhile. Without it, if someone came to confess an abortion, a priest would need to ask permission anonymously of the diocese or the sacred penitentiary at the Vatican for the ability to remove the censure incurred so that he could absolve the sins. In ordinary parish work, it’s not too much to ask someone to come back tomorrow. But that would be practically impossible at WYD for a particular penitent to find a particular confessor again. This is such a no-brainer from the sacramental point of view — and is ordinary for the course, at least in the U.S.”
No less than the Pope in Rome, the now Blessed Pope John Paul II, wrote explicitly, in his 1995 encyclical on Evangelium Vitae: “I would now like to say a special word to women who have had an abortion. The Church is aware of the many factors which may have influenced your decision, and she does not doubt that in many cases it was a painful and even shattering decision. The wound in your heart may not yet have healed.
Certainly what happened was and remains terribly wrong. But do not give in to discouragement, and do not lose hope. Try, rather, to understand what happened, and face it honestly. If you have not already done so, give yourselves over with humility and trust to repentance. The Father of mercies is ready to give you his forgiveness and his peace in the sacrament of reconciliation. To the same Father and his mercy, you can, with sure hope, entrust your child. With the friendly and expert help and advice of other people, and as a result of your own painful experience, you can be among the most eloquent defenders of everyone’s right to life. Through your commitment to life, whether by accepting the birth of other children or by welcoming and caring for those most in need of someone to be close to them, you will become promoters of a new way of looking at human life.”
That I cut and pasted from the Vatican’s website, by the way. And there was nothing about having to wait for a few days in Madrid (time is running out!!!) in 2011.
“The Church has always been there offering forgiveness,” Theresa Bonapartis, who works with post-abortive women and men in New York, tells me. But she worries: “We just do not talk about it as much as we should. I think some people are afraid to because they think if we do people are going to think they can abort because they know they can be forgiven. I guess, in some ways, there is a truth to that because there are some abortion clinics who say ‘God understands; don’t you think he will forgive you?’ while they are actually in the process of killing their child, which of course, is very different. They forget you have to be contrite and have firm purpose of amending your life.”
She adds: “In many ways, confession is the beginning of healing. I believe you cannot look at the horror of your abortion until you know the love and forgiveness of God. Knowing his unconditional love is what allows you to look at your abortion honestly.”
But you wouldn’t know that from many of the stories you’re reading this week.
“God is kind and merciful. There is no one who is beyond the pale of his redemption. There is no one whom God cannot redeem and use for his purposes,” Los Angeles Archbishop Jose Gomez wrote around the memorial of St. Mary Magdalene in July. “I worry,” he added, “sometimes that we might be forgetting that in our society.”
Clearly, there is reason to worry. And pray.
“People make mistakes,” Archbishop Gomez wrote. “They sin. Some people do evil that causes scandal and grave harm. We can condemn the offense and work for justice — without trying to destroy the person who committed the sin. We are called in all things to charity and truth, kindness and empathy.”
“The life of Mary Madgalene is a reminder that God is always merciful — even if we are not,” Archbishop Gomez wrote.
In a brochure, the Sisters of Life — women whose lives are dedicated to building a culture of life and healing pain from the culture of death — offer an invitation to “Hope and Healing After Abortion.” Bonapartis emphasizes the need to take a few steps back from the heat of politics. Yes, there is a grave sin there. But, a post-abortive woman herself, who has devoted her life to helping women, and men, avoid abortion and seek forgiveness: “We have lost our children, and we need to be allowed to grieve for them,” she writes. That in a publication from a group of Catholic nuns, who were established by the late John Cardinal O’Connor and who happen to be running the English-language hub at World Youth Day this year.
Politics isn’t always merciful. Although Rick Santorum sure gave mercy some justice during the Aug. 11 Republican presidential-candidate debate in Iowa. When he was asked if he was too harsh for his party on abortion, he talked about the “trauma” and “violence” of abortion with great compassion.
It’s a harsh world here. It seems to only get harsher with every new-media outlet out for immediate rant gratification. But I’m reminded of the prayer of Mother Mary Agnes Donovan and the Sisters of Life at Cardinal O’Connor’s funeral in 2000: “All of a sudden, the president and his wife were there, and they were never in the cathedral when he was alive. And others of great rank were there, who also would not have been inclined to be there when he was alive. And we were praying from the bottom of our hearts, saying, ‘If this is so, let the truth as he would have told it, be told.’” And so they prayed and prayed and prayed, she recalls: “And when the applause was set off in St. Patrick’s, that was the answer to our prayers. The truth was told: about life, about the preciousness of human life, without a word being said. He told that truth so well in his life, and told it one more time in death.”
We mustn’t let misleading headlines and reporting and angry commentary obscure the truth — and keep our brothers and sisters from justice and mercy. No sin is unforgivable, if we are truly sorry. Pray and pray and pray that truth is heard and embraced.
Kathryn Jean Lopez is editor-at-large of National Review Online and a nationally syndicated columnist.


Comments
Post a Comment
I think there is a lot of anger over the misconception that Catholics and the Church see women who have abortions as “filthy sluts” without feelings, rather than women who made tragic choices. It’s not as if we want these women to be excommunicated, we don’t want them to be punished, because the abortion does that itself. We want to see them heal and seek forgiveness, not burn for eternity.
I’m still frazzled at how often the media get it wrong when it comes to the Church.
For those who are in need of healing after abortion, contact Rachel’s Vineyard (http://www.rachelsvineyard.org). This retreat is the gold standard for post-abortion healing and is the largest post-abortion ministry in the world. The retreat teams serve to help manifest God’s love, mercy, forgiveness and healing.
A great article indeed.why dont you see it all those out there are New York Times ???
After reading this article I popped over to Slate to read the post from Amanda Marcotte…sounds like a very hateful woman indeed, full of rage and self-loathing that she projects onto Holy Mother Church. Either that, or just another angry feminist. The good news is there were plenty of Catholics in the comments column calling out her bigotry. Won’t likely have much of an effect…calling God and Salvation “an evil patriarchal plot by the evil patriarchy and its patriarchs’ is is typical for the products of third-rate Wimmenz Studies Programs…
As a former social worker in the`80’s in Florida, I so remember taking a “fallen away” Catholic to her 1st confession after being away from the Church for over thirty years and having had two abortions along the way. I’m no angel by any measure, but I just crinched as she blightly told me, in guesome detail, about the many other Capital Sins she had comitted during those thirty years. I called ahead and made an appointment with the priest in her parish. When I went inside with her, true to his word, the young priest met us at baptismal font and wisked her away to the confessional. I kneeled, having brought my Rosary and several prayer books, presuming this would take awhile, giving me a chance to really pray for her soul as well as my own. But to my shock, within just a few minutes, she was out of the confessional and up front to say an Our Father, a Glory Be, and two decades of the Rosary. A few seconds later, Father returned to his rectory, and the woman I had brought to Church was strolling back up the aisle toward me a relieved grin on her face. I don’t pretend to know what went on in that confessional, but from what she told me beforehand, I figured she’d be in the confessional for at least fifteen minutes. My question: In the eighties, did they teach priests a course entitled, “The Five Minute Confession?”
I was surprised to read that the the Church was offering absolution for Catholic women who had had abortions during WYD. I too, thought all sin was forgivable. If murderers and child abusers can be forgiven, why not those who have aborted their children. Aborted babies pray for their mothers in heaven. If their was no hope, why would they do that.
I can only pray that the members of our liberal media would just once do a little topic research before their all too often degradations of the church and the teachings of the church. They seem to be under the impression that the values, traditions, sacraments, and indeed the entire catechism of the catholic church is nothing more than some made up rules designed to belittle sinners, and that the only function of God is to punish what the church says is evil. If the media were to suddenly become responsible and research God and the church, they would discover that God and the church are infinitely more concerned with love and salvation of souls that punishment for sin. It’s just the all too prevalent attitude that finding fault in others makes them feel better about themselves. The bigger the target, the better for their news sales. They also cannot understand that pointing their finger and saying shame shame only reflects their vindictiveness back upon themselves. HEY MEDIA!!!!! PEACE!!!!!!
I’m sorry, are women committing these sexual sins in a vacuum? I do not understand WHY everything about abortion forgiveness in the Catholic media is addressed almost exclusively to only WOMEN. It’s even so in what our BELOVED (and I *do* love him) Blessed John Paul II wrote in Article 99 of his 1995 encyclical on Evangelium Vitae. Even Archbishop Gomez only refers to Mary Magdalene when he talks about forgiveness for sexual sin. I’ll bet you Jesus knew that alot of the men that wanted to stone her, wanted to because they had slept with her! As for today’s high abortion numbers, so often women have abortions because they have NO support from the baby’s father by whom they conceived. And so many of these women (and men) were, in so many cases, raised in angry, sin-sick families - i.e. absent fathers, abusive fathers, alcoholic mothers.. the list goes on. If they’re going to address the need for abortion forgiveness and healing, they need to address it to EVERYONE, the mothers, the fathers, the abortion workers. Everyone needs healing. Abortion is a nightmare that must end, and it will, but only when we acknowledge that *everyone* needs forgiveness and healing, and HOPE. Not just the mothers.
Jesus’ generosity in forgiving others, in an envious soul, must seem like an absurdity. These folks are blinded, by their sins. Pray, and do penance for them, to run back, into the arms of Jesus! Rosaries, Masses, Novenas, simple prayer and sacrifices for them will move them eventually. “Jesus, I trust in You!”
It’s disheartening to see the Catholic Church to continue to scare away people from religion. Kathryn, I went to Catholic school and had the greatest time of my life there. It was a wonderful environment with priests who loved and cared for us. None of them made us fearful of our own religion.
Jesus forgives before we ask for forgiveness. Jesus forgave those who killed him before they killed him. They didn’t ask for forgiveness, it was already given. LUKE 23:34 Then Jesus said, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they do.”
For years the Catholic Church dismissed Darwinism. Thousands of years later, they said it was compatible with creationism. That paradigm shift had to happen because the world was changing.
I will never see abortion as being right. Yet I know that Catholic Church needs to do something to stop condemning young women who are confused enough about themselves and their faith. God loves them and forgives them because he is their father.
God bless you, Kathryn for your thoughtful, helpful article. Father Zuhlsdorf (wdtprs.com) has posted on canonical issue of forgiveness vs lifting of censure/excommunication (which is what this is about). But, as you point out, this is not how it’s portrayed in the media, resulting in the harm of many souls. I respect, appreciate and commend the charity you practice throughout your articles, especially the closing paragraph of this one. May God grant me His grace to practice charity as well as you do.
I @ Friday, Aug 19, 2011 10:05 AM:
It isn’t that abortion is unforgivable without special permission from a bishop - any priest who can forgive sins can forgive that sin. What the priests at World Youth Day needed permission to “fix” is the excommunication that goes along with that sin.
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.