Current Issue

Print Edition: May 19, 2013

Sign-up for our E-letter!



 

  • Donate
  • Archives
  • Blogs
  • Store
  • Resources
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • Radio
  • Subscribe
  • Make This
    My Homepage
  • Resources
  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Books
  • Commentary
  • Culture of Life
  • Education
  • In Person
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Sunday Guides
  • Travel
  • Vatican
  • Dan Burke
  • Jeanette DeMelo
  • Edward Pentin
  • Mark Shea
  • Matthew Warner
  • Jimmy Akin
  • Matt & Pat Archbold
  • Simcha Fisher
  • Tito Edwards
  • Jennifer Fulwiler
  • Steven D. Greydanus
  • Tom Wehner
  • Our Latest Show
  • About the Show
  • About the Register
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • Stations
  • Schedule
  • Other EWTN Shows
  • Advertising Overview
  • Editorial Calendar
  • Order Web Ad
  • Order Print Ad
Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us
Print Edition » News

Moot Point: Voters Reject Obamacare

Symbolic Gesture Passed in Five States

  • Tweet
by Brian Fraga, Register Correspondent Monday, Nov 12, 2012 6:11 PM Comments (1)

In largely symbolic ballot measures, five states allowed voters on Election Day the opportunity to show their disapproval of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, dubbed Obamacare.

The measures were symbolic because the U.S. Supreme Court already ruled this past summer that the federal health-care law is constitutional, thus making moot any state-level efforts to nullify the federal law.

On Nov. 6, similar health-care amendments were on the ballot in Alabama, Florida, Wyoming and Montana. The amendments allowed residents in those states the option to purchase health insurance or not, which the Affordable Care Act compels all Americans to do in what is called the individual mandate.

In Missouri, a ballot question sought to prevent the Show-Me State from having to set up its own health-insurance exchange, which all states are required to do by Nov. 16.

The Alabama Health Care Amendment — Amendment 6 on the state ballot — passed by a 58% margin, with 738,905 voters approving it and 543,946 voting against. The amendment is supposed to prohibit mandatory participation in any health-care system, which would block the Affordable Care Act from taking effect in that state.

Alabama Gov. Robert Bentley told reporters in Huntsville on Nov. 6 that he favored the effort to amend the Alabama Constitution to prevent the federal health-care law from being implemented in his state.

"The worst piece of legislation that has ever been passed in my lifetime by Congress is this ‘Affordable Health Care Act,’" the governor said, according to AL.com.

"It is not affordable, and it is not health care. It is the worst — ah, I said that. I don’t have to say it twice," Bentley said.

AL.com also reported that Bentley said he did not know if his state will set up its health-insurance exchange by Nov. 16. Alabama missed a deadline last month to submit a list of health-care benefits that would be offered on its exchange to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

In Florida, a similar health-care ballot question failed, with 52% of people voting against the amendment. The measure would have required 60% of voters approving it in order to amend the Florida Constitution.

The Republican-controlled state Legislature in Florida pushed the amendment as a way to send a strong political message against Obamacare. The Florida Health Care Amendment aimed to prevent laws or rules from compelling any person or employer to purchase, obtain or provide health insurance.

Florida state lawmakers tried to get a similar measure on the ballot in 2010, but that state’s Supreme Court prevented those efforts, ruling that the proposed ballot question’s summary was inaccurate and misleading. The Sunshine State’s former attorney general, shortly after President Barack Obama signed his health-care reform into law in 2010, filed a lawsuit against the law.

Meanwhile, in Montana, a similar health-care amendment passed on Nov. 6, with 47,920 people (64.58%) casting votes in favor and 26,281 votes against (35%).

The Montana Health Care Amendment allows residents in that state the choice to decide if they want health insurance or not and which health insurance to buy if they choose to do so.

Voters in Wyoming approved essentially the same amendment to the Wyoming Constitution, with 124,987 people voting for the measure and 36,022 against. The Wyoming amendment says: "No federal or state law, rule or administrative decision shall compel, directly or indirectly, any person, employer or health-care provider to participate in any health-care system."

Wyoming, Alabama and Montana join Arizona and Oklahoma as states that have amended their constitutions in attempts to prevent the implementation of the Affordable Care Act.

The so-called Obamacare federal law was controversial from the start. Not a single Republican lawmaker voted for it. Republican leaders in the U.S. House of Representatives have tried unsuccessfully to repeal the law, while 28 states filed joint or individual lawsuits to overturn its individual mandate that compels all Americans to obtain health insurance.

The Affordable Care Act also empowered Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to issue a mandate that employers must provide coverage in their employee health-insurance plans — without deductibles or co-pays — for all government-approved forms of birth control, including abortion-inducing drugs and sterilization.

On June 28, the U.S. Supreme Court, after having heard three days of oral arguments in March, upheld the Affordable Care Act by a 5-4 margin — Chief Justice John Roberts, one of six Catholics on the court, was the decisive vote — on the grounds that the law’s financial penalty for individuals who don’t obtain health insurance is a tax, which the Constitution allows Congress to collect.

The Supreme Court’s upholding of the Affordable Care Act in essence regulates the state amendments to mere symbolic status because the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause guarantees that federal law trumps state law.

That holds true, as well, for a Missouri ballot amendment that 63% of voters approved to prevent their state from being forced to institute its own health-insurance exchange. The amendment — Proposition E — symbolically grants the authority to make decisions about the exchange to the state Legislature and voters.

However, the Affordable Care Act already empowers the federal government to set up "federally facilitated exchanges" in 2014 for states that choose not to create their own exchanges.

Brian Fraga writes from

Fall River, Massachusetts.

Filed under

Comments

Post a Comment
Posted by Jay Junk on Sunday, Nov 25, 2012 12:12 PM (EDT):

So now let’s move on.  ACA will benefit millions of uninsured especially children.  Catholics should be in favor of this.

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.

Also in this Issue

  • Arts & Culture

    The Secret Life of Video Arcade Characters
  • Blu-ray/DVD Picks & Passes 11.18.12
  • Commentary

    Transhumanism: Taking the Place of Our Creator
  • Drone Wars: The Morality of Robotic Weapons
  • Hope in God
  • Culture of Life

    The National Catholic Register's Christmas Gift Guide 2012
  • Catholics, Be Thankful Always and Everywhere
  • Friends in High Places
  • Inspire Hard Work
  • Why Do Catholics ...?
  • Babies Saved
  • Education

    College Students and Others Rally for the Unborn
  • In Person

    Pastor Weathers Hurricane Sandy and Its Aftermath
  • News

    President Obama’s Government Support Proved More Popular
  • HHS Threat Undiminished
  • Vatican Seeks to Ease Mideast Tensions
  • Religious-Freedom Amendments Tumble
  • Opinion

    The Challenge for Catholics
  • ‘The Same, Yesterday, Today, Forever’
  • Letters 11.18.12
  • Vatican

    Pope Benedict’s 'Little Consistory'
  • Lighting the Spark Plug of Grace
  • Road Map for the New Evangelization

Most Popular Now

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (6844)
  • Commentary

    Man or Beast: The Modern Dilemma (4547)
  • Arts & Entertainment

    ‘Verily’ Promotes True Femininity (4310)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (3321)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (2055)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (2025)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (1542)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (1300)
  • Culture of Life

    The Hope of Easter (1254)
  • Sunday Guides

    Christ Isn’t in the Sky (817)
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (125)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (35)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (11)
  • Commentary

    Man or Beast: The Modern Dilemma (9)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (7)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (5)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (4)
  • Commentary

    Kermit Gosnell Trial a Potential Game Changer (2)
  • Culture of Life

    Why Do Catholics ...? (1)
  • Sunday Guides

    Three Weekly Easter Lessons (1)
 
Close

Free Newsletter Sign-Up

Enter your e-mail address below to receive the latest news and blog posts in your inbox each day.

As part of this free service you will receive occasional free offers from us. We won’t share your information, and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
Click here if you don't want this message to show again.

National Catholic Register

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Press Releases
  • RSS Daily Register
  • RSS Bloggers
  • RSS Print
  • Contact
  • Jobs

Copyright © 2013 EWTN News, Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction of material from this website without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Accessed from 54.234.180.187