National Catholic Register


Maher the Adolescent

BY Tom Hoopes

| Posted 10/11/08 at 1:00 PM


More readers are learning that “Bill Maher Makes an Adolescent Case Against Religion in Religulous.” That’s because the review by Village Voice film critic J. Hoberman is being picked up by many alternative papers. The Houston Press, for instance

Hoberman judges the movie “Initially quite funny in its head-on engagement with star-spangled, self-righteous platitudes.” But the movie takes a turn for the worse when Maher visits a small North Carolina chapel and harangues congregants. Such unplanned confrontations favored the challenger. Especially since the challenger then got to heavily edit the results.

“Such one-sided encounters are more depressing than fun,” writes Hoberman. Much of the movie has Maher debating “straw men” he says. “It’s far less enjoyable to watch him bait an anti-Zionist Hasid, a barely coherent Scottish Muslim, a guy who claims to be a descendant of Jesus, the proprietor of a creationist museum of natural history or a Dutch pothead who runs a ‘cannabis ministry.’”

In this week’s issue of the Register, you’ll find our very own Steven D. Greydanus’ even better review of the movie.

And at the Catholic League, Bill Donohue, who has chronicled anti-Catholic statements by Bill Maher for years, scores some points as well, judging the movie “More Absurd Than Hateful.

— Tom Hoopes