Current Issue

Print Edition: May 19, 2013

Sign-up for our E-letter!



 

  • Donate
  • Archives
  • Blogs
  • Store
  • Resources
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • Radio
  • Subscribe
  • Make This
    My Homepage
  • Resources
  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Books
  • Commentary
  • Culture of Life
  • Education
  • In Person
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Sunday Guides
  • Travel
  • Vatican
  • Dan Burke
  • Jeanette DeMelo
  • Edward Pentin
  • Mark Shea
  • Matthew Warner
  • Jimmy Akin
  • Matt & Pat Archbold
  • Simcha Fisher
  • Tito Edwards
  • Jennifer Fulwiler
  • Steven D. Greydanus
  • Tom Wehner
  • Our Latest Show
  • About the Show
  • About the Register
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • Stations
  • Schedule
  • Other EWTN Shows
  • Advertising Overview
  • Editorial Calendar
  • Order Web Ad
  • Order Print Ad
Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us
Print Edition » News

Criminal Thoughts?

U.S. Congress Trying to Pass Hate Crimes Legislation

  • Tweet
by TIMOTHY P. CARNEY, REGISTER CORRESPONDENT Tuesday, Aug 21, 2007 3:29 PM Comment

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Congress is close to passing a “hate crimes” bill that would extend special federal protections to homosexuals, transsexuals, women and the disabled.

The legislation, stalled for the summer, has drawn opposition from groups who describe it as a federal overreach or fear it could lead to restrictions on free speech.

Sen. Ted Kennedy, D-Mass., is the chief sponsor of the Matthew Shepard Act, named after a 21-year-old Wyoming man beaten to death in 1998 because of his homosexuality. The bill would broaden federal “hate crimes” laws, which currently cover violent crimes motivated by race, religion and national origin. Kennedy’s bill would expand the federal definition of “hate crimes” to include violent crimes motivated by gender, disability, sexual orientation or “gender identity.”

While most assaults, robberies, murders or kidnappings are state offenses, “hate crimes” would be federal offenses under Kennedy’s bill.

The bill would direct federal tax dollars to state and local government to assist in the prosecution of “hate crimes.”

Some fear this bill would be a first step towards laws prohibiting “hate speech,” such as those in Europe and Canada. Kennedy’s bill is explicitly limited to acts of violence, but that hasn’t kept some Christian organizations from warning of a “slippery slope” toward speech codes.

The measure passed the House of Representatives as a stand-alone bill on May 3 by a 237-180 margin. Kennedy inserted the measure into an amendment to a defense-spending bill (non-germane amendments are very common in the Senate), but that spending bill was delayed by debates over Iraq.

Kennedy spokeswoman Laura Capps indicated her boss would resume his push for this legislation after the August recess.

“We’re always looking for vehicles for this important legislation,” Capps said.

While the bill is stalled for now, Capps expressed confidence they would pass it into law, pointing out that three years ago, under Republican control, the Senate passed the measure 65-33, again attached to a defense-funding bill.

Opponents in Congress raise two main objections to the bill: It needlessly extends federal power into matters properly handled by the state, and it violates the Constitution’s equal protection guarantees.

The bill claims that “hate crimes” are under the jurisdiction of Congress because such crimes “substantially affect interstate commerce in many ways.”

One House Republican aide called this justification “very thin.”

Free Speech Issue

Another central objection is that the bill is discriminatory: It appears to create special protected classes of citizens, whose attackers are prosecuted more aggressively and more harshly than other criminals.

“This bill divides people by class and color,” argued one House Republican staffer.

Some groups oppose the bill, comparing it to laws in Europe and Canada outlawing “hate speech.” Jim Jenkins, senior legal counsel at the Alliance Defense Fund calls the bill “a Trojan horse,” and a “sneaky way to suppress free speech.” Jenkins argues that in “almost every place that hate crimes legislation has been passed, hate speech legislation has followed.”

After the bill passed the House in May, Family Research Council President Tony Perkins issued a statement to that effect: “In some jurisdictions that have adopted similar laws, ‘hate crimes’ have been defined to include not just physical acts of violence but merely verbal ones, as well. When ‘thought crimes’ laws are interpreted this way, they pose a serious threat to freedom of speech and religious liberty.”

Capps, Kennedy’s spokeswoman, said that the bill “doesn’t at all impact speech.”

The bill defines a hate crime as “a crime in which the defendant intentionally selects a victim, or in the case of a property crime, the property that is the object of the crime, because of the actual or perceived race, color, religion, national origin, ethnicity, gender, disability or sexual orientation of any person,” and the federal penalties only cover those who “willfully cause bodily harm” — language that appears not to cover speech or expression.

Many European countries and Canada have laws prohibiting “hate speech,” which often include Christian teaching that homosexual behavior is disordered and immoral. In Sweden, for example, a preacher was convicted of hate speech after one of his sermons was published in a local newspaper. Spanish Cardinal Antonio Maria Ruoco has been sued for slander after his criticism of homosexual “marriage.”

Helen Osmond, spokeswoman for the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, said, “At this point we do not” have a position on the bill.

Considering that the bill has passed the House this Congress and garnered a large majority in a Republican-dominated Congress three years ago, the measure likely will pass Congress this year, either as a rider on a larger bill or as a stand-alone measure.

Tim Carney writes from

Washington, D.C.

Filed under

Comments

Post a Comment

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.

Also in this Issue

  • Arts & Culture

    TV Picks AUG. 26 - Sept. 1
  • DVD Picks & Passes
  • Crossing the Bridge to Trust
  • Anthropomorphic Agenda
  • Commentary

    The Teacher as Artist
  • Patriotism As Idolatry
  • Oligarchy of the Media
  • Culture of Life

    ‘St. Monica Miracles’ Still Happen
  • Ditch the Misery Meter
  • Children Welcome
  • Education

    Reading and Evangelizing
  • In Person

    Catholic ‘Revert’ Silent No More
  • News

    Stupak’s Struggle
  • Saga of Sacred Stones
  • Peru Rises
  • Coming to A State Near You
  • Opinion

    Suffering With God
  • Letters
  • Events Online and Suggestion Box
  • Vatican

    Pope Benedict on the Sermon on the Mount

Most Popular Now

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Culture of Life

    Age-Old Prayer Gains More Pray-ers (7821)
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (7572)
  • Arts & Entertainment

    ‘Verily’ Promotes True Femininity (4443)
  • Opinion

    Pentecost, Prudence and Immigration Reform (3550)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (3517)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (2138)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (2126)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (1609)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (1368)
  • Sunday Guides

    The Holy Spirit’s Two Comings (1237)
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (126)
  • Opinion

    Pentecost, Prudence and Immigration Reform (53)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (35)
  • Culture of Life

    Age-Old Prayer Gains More Pray-ers (21)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (11)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (7)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (5)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (4)
  • Culture of Life

    Kansas for Life (2)
  • Culture of Life

    The Gift of the Holy Spirit (1)
 
Close

Free Newsletter Sign-Up

Enter your e-mail address below to receive the latest news and blog posts in your inbox each day.

As part of this free service you will receive occasional free offers from us. We won’t share your information, and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
Click here if you don't want this message to show again.

National Catholic Register

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Press Releases
  • RSS Daily Register
  • RSS Bloggers
  • RSS Print
  • Contact
  • Jobs

Copyright © 2013 EWTN News, Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction of material from this website without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Accessed from 184.72.91.94