Current Issue

Print Edition: May 19, 2013

Sign-up for our E-letter!



 

  • Donate
  • Archives
  • Blogs
  • Store
  • Resources
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • Radio
  • Subscribe
  • Make This
    My Homepage
  • Resources
  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Books
  • Commentary
  • Culture of Life
  • Education
  • In Person
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Sunday Guides
  • Travel
  • Vatican
  • Dan Burke
  • Jeanette DeMelo
  • Edward Pentin
  • Mark Shea
  • Matthew Warner
  • Jimmy Akin
  • Matt & Pat Archbold
  • Simcha Fisher
  • Tito Edwards
  • Jennifer Fulwiler
  • Steven D. Greydanus
  • Tom Wehner
  • Our Latest Show
  • About the Show
  • About the Register
  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • Stations
  • Schedule
  • Other EWTN Shows
  • Advertising Overview
  • Editorial Calendar
  • Order Web Ad
  • Order Print Ad
Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us
Print Edition » Commentary

Catholic Courageous: Pryor Faces Schumer

  • Tweet
by Kathryn Jean Lopez Sunday, Jul 06, 2003 2:00 PM Comment

Alabama Attorney General William Pryor can take comfort in the beatitude "blessed are the persecuted" these days.

And he'd better. He has found little else in the U.S. Senate.

His nomination to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals continues to be mired by Senate Democrats. His nomination's fate is uncertain, but, in the end, the man looks to be on his way to excellent eternal standing — if public witness under fire gets brownie points at the pearly gates. And, when it comes to the things of this world, if he loses his current fight, it will not be because he did not put up a fight and perform near flawlessly.

When Pryor sat at the hearing table in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee on June 11, the Senate Democrats, who have heretofore faced principled but somewhat demure judicial nominees, had no idea what they were up against.

They came prepared, mind you. Their strategy: demonize the nominee on abortion, homosexuality and partisan politics. Make him look like an extremist, and make sure they know he is a papist.

Bill Pryor, a Catholic pro-life father and husband, is a public official with a public record that shows he's no fan of Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that legalized abortion in America. He has called Roe “the worst abomination in the history of constitutional law.”

Senate Democrats had stalled plenty of pro-life nominations previously. They stopped Texas Supreme Court judge Priscilla Owen because she ruled in favor of an abortion parental-notification statute. They stopped Miguel Estrada, who was up for a seat on the District of Columbia Court of Appeals and is pro-life, like most Hispanics — which means he's out.

Naturally, they weren't going to overlook Pryor's line about the “abomination.” Surely he would take it back, they must have thought.

Well, he didn't. Nor did he soften it. He told it like it is. “Do you believe that now?” Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., asked Pryor.

“I do,” Pryor replied. In shock, Schumer thanked Pryor for his “candor.”

It didn't end there, however. Pryor later told the committee:

“I believe that not only is [Roe] unsupported by the text and structure of the Constitution, but it has [also] led to a morally wrong result. It has led to the slaughter of millions of innocent unborn children.”

He has also said he “will never forget Jan. 22, 1973 [the day of the Roe decision], the day seven members of our highest court ripped up the Constitution” and that the Supreme Court had created “out of thin air a constitutional right to murder an unborn child.”

No one at this point was going to drop this line of questioning. One of the senators on his side asked Pryor to clarify the statement, “I believe that abortion is the taking of human life.” He answered, “I believe that abortion is morally wrong.”

That's probably the last thing anyone watching the hearing would have expected to hear from the nominee — from any nominee.

And it got more contentious — and ridiculous, if that was possible.

Sen. Russell Feingold, D-Wis., trying to demonize Pryor as a hater of gay people, asked: “News accounts also report that you even went so far as to reschedule a family vacation at Disney World in order to avoid Gay Day. In light of this record, can you understand why a gay plaintiff or defendant would feel uncomfortable coming before you as a judge?”

Pryor answered, “As far as my family vacation is concerned, my wife and I had two daughters who at the time of that vacation were 6 and 4, and we made a value judgment. And that was our personal decision.”

The exchange continued:

Feingold: “Well, I certainly respect going to Disney World with two daughters. I've done the same thing. But are you saying that you actually made that decision on purpose to be away at the time of that?”

Pryor: “We made a value judgment and changed our plan and went another weekend.

Feingold: “Well, I — I appreciate your candor on that.”

As if to confirm what the hearing was all about, Schumer told the committee, “[Pryor's] beliefs are so deeply held that it's very difficult to believe those views won't influence how he follows the law. A person's views matter.”

He said to Pryor, “Your record screams passionate advocate but does-n't so much as whisper judge.”

The fact of the matter is that Pryor is a well-respected lawyer. He's proved himself as dutiful, willing to uphold the law even when he disagrees with it. As attorney general he told state district attorneys to take “the narrowest construction available” when dealing with the state's partial-birth-abortion law, following Supreme Court precedent.

So what is wrong with Pryor? Schumer told us. And it raises the question: Can a pro-life Catholic survive a Senate confirmation process? Would one ever survive a Supreme Court confirmation? Are we even fit for public office?

Pryor meanwhile waits to be granted the imprimatur of the Senate Judiciary Committee. When Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., asked the Alabama attorney general what his religion is, Catholics especially should have stood at attention.

Kathryn Jean Lopez is editor ofNational Review Online and an associate editor of National Review.

Filed under

Comments

Post a Comment

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.

Also in this Issue

  • Arts & Culture

    Weekly TV Picks
  • Weekly Video/DVD Picks
  • Spotlight: Watching silent films with children
  • Now Playing
  • Commentary

    C.S. Lewis Finds Irish Catholics In Outer Space
  • Culture of Life

    St. Benedict’s Bounty
  • Family Matters
  • Heavenly Hospitality
  • Education

    Campus Watch
  • Weekly Book Pick Chesterton for the Common Man
  • Villanova Law School Bans Abortion Internships
  • In Person

    Leading Lutheran Pastor Becomes Catholic
  • News

    Hunting Superman
  • Notre Dame Students Feel Faith Is Under Attack
  • Media Watch
  • Hebrew-Language Mass in the Holy Land: Will It Worsen Divisions?
  • News In Brief
  • Senate Judiciary Committee Grills Catholic Nominee on Abortion Views
  • Media Watch
  • Judge Rules Against Florida Woman’s Right to Live; Family Will Appeal
  • RU-486 Users Suffering
  • Hospital Sells Rather Than Stop Performing Tubals
  • Notre Dame to Parents: We Won’t Tell
  • Supreme Court Rulings Drop Three Bombshells
  • Opinion

    Husbands, Wives and Discerning Family Size
  • Encouraging Sodomy
  • Vatican

    Virtual Vatican Museums
  • Remembering Pope Paul VI
  • Media Watch
  • Pope Asks God’s Forgiveness for Bosnia Region’s Suffering

Most Popular Now

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (6829)
  • Commentary

    Man or Beast: The Modern Dilemma (4546)
  • Arts & Entertainment

    ‘Verily’ Promotes True Femininity (4299)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (3302)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (2053)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (2022)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (1540)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (1297)
  • Culture of Life

    The Hope of Easter (1252)
  • Sunday Guides

    Christ Isn’t in the Sky (815)
  • Commentary

    ‘Gay Marriage’ or Religious Freedom: You Can’t Have Both (125)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Our Lady of Fatima: Spend ‘A Day With Mary’ (35)
  • Opinion

    Hope Amid Horror (11)
  • Commentary

    Man or Beast: The Modern Dilemma (9)
  • Sunday Guides

    Imagine There’s No Heaven? (7)
  • Culture of Life

    Honor Mom (5)
  • Culture of Life

    Moms, Imitate the Mother of God’s Virtues (4)
  • Commentary

    Kermit Gosnell Trial a Potential Game Changer (2)
  • Culture of Life

    Why Do Catholics ...? (1)
  • Sunday Guides

    Three Weekly Easter Lessons (1)
 
Close

Free Newsletter Sign-Up

Enter your e-mail address below to receive the latest news and blog posts in your inbox each day.

As part of this free service you will receive occasional free offers from us. We won’t share your information, and you can unsubscribe at anytime.
Click here if you don't want this message to show again.

National Catholic Register

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Subscriptions
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Press Releases
  • RSS Daily Register
  • RSS Bloggers
  • RSS Print
  • Contact
  • Jobs

Copyright © 2013 EWTN News, Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction of material from this website without written permission is strictly prohibited.
Accessed from 107.20.129.212