This past decade has seen a plethora of movies dealing with superheroes: the Batman films, The Green Lantern, Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk, Thor, etc. But the most popular — at least judging by box-office receipts — has been the Spider-Man franchise. Since 2002, there have been four major movie adaptations of the Marvel Comics story of a kid who gets bitten by a spider, undergoes a stunning metamorphosis, and then “catches thieves just like flies.”
What is it about these stories — and the Spider-Man tale in particular — that fascinate us? May I suggest that it has something to do with Christianity; more precisely, with the strange hybrid figure around which all of the Christian religion revolves. St. Athanasius’s most significant contribution to the Christological debates of the early centuries of the Church’s life was a soteriological argument for the dual nature of Jesus. In the saint’s pithy formula: Only a human being could save us; and only God could save us. If Jesus were only divine — as the Monophysites argued — then his saving power wouldn't be truly applied to us. If he were only human — as the Arians and Nestorians argued — then he could not really lift us out of the morass of sin and guilt in which we find ourselves mired. In a word, salvation was possible only through a God-man, someone in the world but not of it, someone like us in all things but sin, and at the same time utterly unlike us.
I can't help but hear an echo of the ancient Christological doctrine in the latest crop of films featuring Batman and Superman and Spider-Man. All three of these superheroes are hybrid combinations of the extraordinary and the ordinary. In all three cases we have someone who, in his lowliness, is able completely to identify and sympathize with our suffering and, in his transcendence, is able to do something about it. A particular charm of the recently released The Amazing Spider-Man is Andrew Garfield: The actor who plays Peter Parker is quite obviously an ordinary and, even geeky, kid who at decisive moments gracefully demonstrates godlike powers.
Another obliquely Christological feature of the new Spider Man film — and in some of the other superhero movies as well — is the motif of mission and vocation. Once aware that he is in full possession of stunning physical capabilities, Peter mercilessly taunts an obnoxious classmate who had some time before humiliated him. His Uncle Ben, skillfully underplayed by the always watchable Martin Sheen, quickly upbraids the young man for indulging a crude desire for revenge.
Precisely how he should use the gifts he has discovered emerges as perhaps the central theme of the movie. Should he use them as the means to aggrandize his ego and settle old scores? Or should he make them ingredient in a program of protection and service — a program of love?
Both Matthew and Luke portray Jesu, at the beginning of his public career wrestling with the meaning and implication of his Messiahship. He indeed knew himself to be the beloved Son of his heavenly Father, but what did this identity entail?
The classical interpretation of these accounts of Jesus’ time in the desert is that the Lord confronted and finally resisted the temptation to use his Messianic authority for the acquisition of sensual pleasure, for the puffing up of his ego and for power. It is the conviction of the Church that every baptized and confirmed person has been equipped with gifts from the Holy Spirit, which are participations in the identity of Christ Jesus.
The whole drama of an individual’s life hinges on the decision concerning the use of those gifts. As Peter Parker’s literature professor puts it towards the end of the film, “There is finally only one plot line to every story ever written; namely, who am I?”
A third theological theme in The Amazing Spider-Man — and in the Batman movies, Iron Man and The Avengers as well — is that of knowledge and the abuse of knowledge. When the Spider Man comics were written in the 1950s, during the Cold War, there was a great deal of concern in the general culture about the way science was being used for less than constructive purposes.
In the current film, Peter Parker’s father and his colleague, Dr. Connors, are endeavoring through biological research to perfect the technique of mixing species in order to address a variety of human ailments and deformities. Their motives might have been laudable, but their hubris was unconstrained; and the results of their overreaching proved a disaster.
The biblical story of original sin centers on an act of grasping at knowledge. This is not tantamount to a disavowal of knowledge as such; but it is indeed a warning that the use of knowledge as a means of achieving godlike control over nature is nefarious. The conceit that we can eliminate all suffering — physical, political, psychological — through the exercise of reason has invariably resulted in an increase in suffering, as the secularist ideologies of the last century amply prove. Though Jesus certainly cured some, the heart of his salvific work was not the total eradication of human pain, but precisely his own embrace of it. This indispensable Christ move, I would argue, is present in almost all of the superhero movies to which I alluded above.
The Amazing Spider-Man and its cinematic cousins might appear to be just summer popcorn movies, but upon closer examination it appears that they carry a considerable amount of theological weight.
This column is courtesy of Catholic News Agency.
Father Robert Barron is the rector of Mundelein Seminary
in the Chicago Archdiocese. He comments on
culture through his Word on Fire Ministry.


Comments
Post a Comment
Excellent article, Father! I enjoy hearing what you have to say, and deeply respect you. Your book Thomas Aquinas: Spiritual Master made me smile, and that’s rare for me with a non-fiction book, even when the subject matter is something I enjoy. (Thomas Aquinas is the saint for whom I was confirmed.)
I think you’ve nailed it down perfectly in terms of what superheroes mean for us. And it isn’t just in the last 100 years, either: what else were mythological demigods if not ideas in the heads of pagans that were subconscious longings for a bridge between the natural and the supernatural because we needed something like that? Likewise, one common theme I see a lot in superhero genres nowadays is jealousy of the superheroes—what else is this jealousy but a desire to be the same thing, which is precisely what Christ offers us?
(One thing, though: Spider-Man was created in 1962, not in the 1950’s. But that’s still the year of the Cuban Missile Crisis. I don’t know why radioactivity became a convenient explanation for the origins of all superheroes/monsters—I look at Barefoot Gen and it seems like a terrible injustice to what happened to all those Japanese people. Which is why I’m glad they did away with the radioactivity in the more recent Spider-Man movies.)
Fr. Barron gives commentary in a way that is easy to read, listen to and explain to my religion classes. Thank you for sharing this article.
Dear Fr Barron: Thank you for this wonderful perspective on Super Heros. Each year in our Confirmation classes, I have part of the program called, “Awakening Your Super Hero”. I ask the students to think if they were a superhero, what would their strength be? How would they use it? Then we talk about the gifts of the Holy Spirit. I compare the gifts that they have with the strength of the Superheros… in the end, Jesus of course is the Ultimate Superhero. But we can be superheros in our own way… by using the gifts that the Holy Spirit has given us to evangelize and to glorify God.
Thank you… I’ve saved the article.
This is a great article and, apart from making me want to see the Amazing Spiderman, which I never would have thought of seeing on my own…it addresses the issue that is so front and center in my own life:
The whole drama of an individual’s life hinges on the decision concerning the use of those gifts [from the Holy Spirit]. As Peter Parker’s literature professor puts it towards the end of the film, “There is finally only one plot line to every story ever written; namely, who am I?”
On a lighter note, the security word I need to enter to post this comment is “probably 39”...well, I can assure you, 39 is definitely something I have NOT been for a long, long time! :-)
Read more: http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/what-christ-can-teach-superheroes/#ixzz2122UL3NG
Dear Father Barron,
In your commentary about superheroes and thir films, you failed too address the motivation for their taking on the hero persona. Truth, justice revenge, thrill of adventure, resposability for order, responsibility that comes with power etc.
I agree when, in another YouTube cast on heroes, that counter-violence is the wrong way.
Yet the superhero inspires others to be better.
Also they have the way to talk about other themes like tolerance and morality.
They hold up a mirror to society. They are the post industrial mythology. Just like Shurlock Holmes, and the others were before them. What separates them from the Saints and our l
Lord is they are fiction. They also differ in their flaws, the crosses in themselves and their world to be overcome.
Blessings from an ardent though convoluted Catholic from Omaha
Tracey
This is rather apt in this current epoch of theological quagmire. I’d define ‘diabolic’ as ‘doing away with,denying the Power,Love of,or man’s need of God- sadly, such movies tend to portray the power of human reasoning as the sole arbiter. Graciàs Padre.
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.