Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us

Daily News

Vatican Reaffirms Inviolability of Seal of Confession (2477)

Official reiterates Church teaching in wake of proposed Irish law that would imprison priests who do not inform civil authorities about cases of sexual abuse revealed to them in the confessional.

08/02/2011 Comments (6)
Wikipedia

Santiago de Compostela Cathedral

– Wikipedia

Rome, Italy, Aug 1, 2011 / 05:56 pm (EWTN News/CNA) — The regent of the apostolic penitentiary, Archbishop Gianfranco Girotti, firmly stated that the Catholic Church will never divulge the confession of a penitent.

“Ireland can pass whatever laws it wants, but it must know that the Church will never submit to forcing confessors to inform civil officials,” said Archbishop Girotti in July 27 statements to Il Foglio.

On July 14, Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny promised to introduce a new law that would establish a prison sentence of five years for priests who do not inform civil authorities about cases of sexual abuse revealed to them in confession.

The proposed law contradicts canon law, which defends the inviolability of the seal of confession and prohibits confessors from breaking it.

Archbishop Girotti said, “A confessor who breaks the seal of confession is subject to latae sententiae excommunication — which is automatic — by the Church,” and, therefore, the proposed measure is “absurd and unacceptable.”

He said, “If they want to violate confession, the Church’s answer will always be ‘No.’”

“All criminals have the duty to render an account of justice for the crimes they have committed, but this does not involve the confessor violating the seal. Confession is meant to cleanse the soul before God,” he added.

Archbishop Girotti said confessors “have the duty to absolve sins, assuming that there is sincere repentance” and that informing civil officials, prison sentences or sanctions established by the laws of the state are another matter.

“Confession is a private affair that allows the penitent to amend and purify himself. The seal is a necessary condition,” he said. “This does not mean that bishops should not guard against pedophiles and, once appropriate investigations have taken place, ask these individuals to pay for their crimes.”

 

 

 

Filed under seal of confession

Comments

Post a Comment

Amen.  The government has no business poking it’s nose into church matters and matters of privacy.  A priest may require a confession as penetence, but that should be left up to the priest.

God help Ireland!  Can’t believe they’d even consider passing a law like this!  Good St.Patrick, intercede for the people of Ireland!!!!

The “separation of Church and state” malarkey is and always has been a one way street.

I guess Ireland doesn’t have a clear constitution that protects Religious freedom. This is just kore religious intolerance that is similar to what Britain is going through. It’ll come back to haunt them and I suppose they’ll eventually change for the better. Pray for those who get hurt in the process.

If the normal mode of confession didn’t include “reconciliation rooms,” but were the way it used to be, with a fixed screen between the confessor and the penitent so that the priest did not know who was confessing, but only what was confessed, the consequences of the proposed Irish law would be moot.

I’m surprised it hasn’t happened here first.

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.