The archbishopric of New York has been held by some larger-than-life personalities. The latest incumbent, who has also taken New York and America by storm, is the gregarious Timothy Dolan.
John Allen sat down with now soon-to-be Cardinal Dolan for some extensive interviews. This book, verbatim selections from those 30-some hours of formal conversation, is the result.
John Allen is a correspondent for the National Catholic Reporter, an “independent Catholic” newspaper. A certain bias flows through the book: Questions about issues like women priests take up a fair chunk of the text. Allen’s context-setting introductions that begin each chapter generally treat Church teaching and dissenters as somewhat on par.
That said, the book is still eminently fair. The bulk of it is in Cardinal Dolan’s own words, so the reader gets the archbishop’s thinking without a filter. And Allen’s critical attitude both gives Cardinal Dolan challenging questions and elicits forthright answers, absent the kind of saccharine adulation that sometimes mars these kinds of interviews.
What emerges is a Timothy Dolan who is a fundamentally hope-filled exponent of what Allen calls “affirmative orthodoxy.” By that term Allen means the Benedict XVI (and John Paul II) project of showing that Catholicism is not some sort of surly, cramped “no” to the contemporary world. It is a positive outlook on the Church in the modern world, a Church whose worldview and moral teaching is animated by a respect for human dignity.
“Somehow we have to recapture the notion that the Church isn’t primarily about running institutions or winning political debates,” the cardinal says. “It’s about reaching deep inside the human heart and stirring what’s best in it, and then boldly going out into the world and insisting that the better angels of our nature can prevail, that cynicism and ego don’t have to be the last word about the kind of culture we pass on to our children, and that the Church is an ally in every positive stirring and hopeful current in that culture. That’s a vision worth devoting one’s life to, and if that’s not affirmative orthodoxy, what is?”
Because Cardinal Dolan and the popes believe that the Church really is the ally of all that is best in and for man, they do not hesitate to reach out to those who might disagree with them, a characteristic readily apparent in the archbishop’s answers.
That’s why Allen believes Cardinal Dolan “could also turn out to be … the American prelate best able to offer a living, breathing model of what affirmative orthodoxy looks, sounds and tastes like.”
Cardinal Dolan does not remain at the level of policy or teaching, but also delves into his own spiritual life: the importance to him of prayer, the centrality of Mass, his role as a confessor and penitent. On the policy level, you might or might not agree with him, but no matter what you think, the archbishop of New York clearly wants to talk about it.
And what he says is certainly worth reading.
John M. Grondelski writes from Perth Amboy, New Jersey.
A PEOPLE OF HOPE:
Archbishop Timothy Dolan in Conversation With John L. Allen Jr.
Image Books, 2012
228 pages, $25
To order: imagecatholicbooks.com
Dan Burke: Prayer for the Souls in Purgatory
Comments
Post a Comment
A point here about Mr. Allen. “A certain bias flows through the book: Questions about issues like women priests take up a fair chunk of the text” I doubt this is actual bias in the typical meaning of the word. John Allen is the only non-biased author I have ever run across on that other paper. He’s just a really good reporter, so I would’t read this as bias. His readers ask these questions, and it is an issues that is being debated in other Catholic circles (as though doctrine was up for debate?) and in the secular world. I would say he’s just doing his job by asking a question that is pertinent to many who claim to be Catholic (however misguided they are).
Important elements of Cardinal Dolan’s affirmative orthodoxy are his visible joy, his confidence and his sense of humor.
The lighter side: The Cardinal and the President:http://sytereitz.com/2012/02/the-cardinal-and-the-president/
Why is the word “fair” always associated with John Allen? This blogpost about him and his treatment of dissenters as being “on par” is worth reading:
http://www.sanctepater.com/2011/05/john-allens-of-national-catholic.html
The National Catholic Register is much too independent for me. It is the flagship of dissidents.
I recall being told by a nun in grade school, that the Church is very slow to change and adapt to modern times. Right after that EVERYTHING seemed to change! We could eat meat on Fridays, the Mass went to the vernacular, confessionals were removed from my parish, as was the Blessed Sacrament-which was put in a side room. The sanctuary lamp went, as did vigil lights and statues. At this point, I think the parish church looks like any other austere Protestant Church. Add to that the disgraceful behavior of some clergy, and the unjust treatment of Homosexuals by the Church,-and you get a good idea why some people have left the Church!
The real issues and the real changes needed are not addressed! Hopefully, the next Pope will be more open to the inspirations of the Holy Spirit!
John Allen was interviewed on NPR radio on June 6, 2012 by David Green regarding the Church’s condemnation of Sr. Farley’s book “Just Love…”. I recommend that you listen to the interview carefully. The tone and subtle slant is apparent to me. The tenant and tone is one of the church being wrong and the Sister correct. Reading a review of one of his interviews with Cardinal Dolan, the reviewer notes an apparent bias also. (John M. Grondelski , Feb 25, 2012) There seemed to be little defense of the church’s position. Perhaps he is incapable of doing so. iT IS For this reason, I suppose that he was the best pick by a liberal media outlet.
Does this guy reflect your editorial positions? Do you approve? If not, Demand a rematch.
http://www.npr.org/2012/06/06/154408069/vatican-criticizes-book-by-catholic-nun
Post a Comment
By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.