African Bishops Pull No Punches Striking Back at ‘Ideological Colonization’

The need to confront the West’s imposition of its values over Africa’s traditional family values is one of the themes the African bishops bring to the synod on the family.

Cardinal Napier is one of the African bishops taking part in the worldwide synod.
Cardinal Napier is one of the African bishops taking part in the worldwide synod. (photo: Bohumil Petrik/CNA)

VATICAN CITY — The African bishops leveled heavy criticism of the West for imposing secular values on their continent in exchange for aid as the Vatican’s synod on the family kicked off its first week.

From press conferences to individual interviews, multiple prelates voiced concern over what Pope Francis has termed “ideological colonization,” in which Western nations have made the acceptance of legislation favoring “gay rights” and “same-sex marriage” contingent on receiving financial aid.

“It’s one thing that the African bishops are very, very conscious of,” Cardinal Wilfrid Napier of Durban, South Africa, told reporters Oct. 7.

“What we are talking about is when countries are told unless you pass certain legislation, you’re not going to get aid from the governments or aid agencies,” he said, pointing to the danger of “political colonization” being replaced “by a different kind of colonization.”

Cardinal Napier held up the example of President Barack Obama’s administration, specifically the president’s visit to Kenya in July. During his two-day trip to the country, Obama spoke out about the importance of gay rights, despite requests from Kenya’s leaders to not address the issue. Homosexual acts are illegal in Kenya, as well as several other African countries. Hillary Clinton as secretary of state “repeated much the same message” to Africa as well, he added.

In an Oct. 8 interview with CNA, Archbishop John Baptist Odama of Gulu and president of the Ugandan Episcopal Conference, called the act “criminal” and said ideologies must never be attached to receiving aid, which is meant to save lives.

“The issue of homosexuality should not be linked with saying, ‘If you don’t accept this, we won’t help you’; that is criminal, I call it criminal,” he said.

“Aid should not be linked with ideological acceptance or rejection. Aid is to save human life. If you link it to ideology, it becomes contradictory ... it is self-defeating,” the archbishop added.

Human beings must be helped without any conditions attached, Archbishop Odama said, adding that the survival of human life “is paramount” and that the family exists precisely to promote human life.

“Any other society, any other groups elsewhere should exist to promote life and protect life, so if it intends to limit the life to be protected or to be accepted to a certain way of thinking, then we run short,” he said.

“So any issue against human life is an issue against humanity in general.”

In an Oct. 8 press briefing with journalists, Archbishop Charles Palmer-Buckle of Accra, Ghana, lamented how some European countries pressured Africa to accept legislation favoring “gay marriage” after Pope Francis made his  2013 “Who am I to judge?” comment on the way back from Rio de Janiero in reference to same-sex attracted individuals authentically seeking Christ.

The comment, he said, “had huge repercussions in our country [Ghana]” and prompted one European country — which he identified as the United Kingdom — “to tell us that if we do not accept these gay marriages and the rest, they were not going to give us financial help.”

“We found it rather very sad that some government could take the sovereignty of another country and say, ‘If you don’t do this, we won’t do that,’” he said, calling the move a “gross violation of what we call the sovereignty of countries.”

Similarly, Cardinal Berhaneyesus Demerew Souraphiel, a member of the Vincentians and archbishop of Addis Ababa in Ethiopia, told CNA Oct. 8 that Africa’s traditional values must be respected.

He recalled how, when Benedict XVI visited Africa in 2011, the Holy Father said that the African continent has “their own values; you are in fact the spiritual lung of the world, and you can become the spiritual lungs of the world, because you have traditional values.”

Protecting those values, such as life and the love and protection of it, is of utmost importance to the African bishops, the cardinal said, explaining that they have already spoken about these issues, and “we will speak about them more, I feel.”