Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us

Daily News

1 Catholic Speaker Gives Way to Another (6956)

Eight out of 10 Americans favor restrictions that would limit abortion. Here comes a speaker who believes that Washington is ‘defying the will of the American people’ on abortion.

11/05/2010 Comments (20)
CNS photo

U.S. House Republican Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio.

– CNS photo

The first woman speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., who has identified herself as “an ardent practicing Catholic,” will soon be the first former woman speaker of the House.

This after being instrumental in the passage of the “biggest expansion of abortion since Roe v. Wade,” as Douglas Johnson of the National Right to Life Committee described the president’s signature health-care legislation when it passed the House in March.

The Democrats’ relegation to minority status coincides with an uptick of Catholics voting Republican during the midterm elections Tuesday — 53% according to CNN exit polls. Among Democrats defeated were some other key players in the passage of the health-care legislation, including a number of self-described pro-life Democrats who ultimately voted for the bill.

Among the “pro-life Democrats” to lose were Kathy Dahlkemper and Paul Kanjorski in Pennsylvania; 14-year incumbent Charlie Wilson, John Boccieri, and Steve Driehaus of Ohio; Brad Ellsworth in Indiana; Jim Oberstar in Minnesota. All were targeted by the pro-life Susan B. Anthony List for defeat in their “Votes Have Consequences” campaign, and Driehaus even made the SBA List go to court in trying to get billboards up in his district informing voters about his vote.

Catholic Republicans elected to seats previously held by Catholic Democrats include Dan Benishek in Michigan (elected to the seat previously held by Bart Stupak, who led the pro-life Democratic opposition to the health-care bill in Congress until the final hours before its passage), Bobby Schilling in Illinois and Sean Duffy in Wisconsin.

The man who will presumably take Pelosi’s speaker’s gavel in January is also a Catholic, John Boehner.

In the days before the election, the Catholic congressman from Ohio told talk radio host Sean Hannity: “We will not compromise on our principles.”  And when asked what he was doing to prep for Election Day and after, he told radio host Mike Gallagher, “I’ve been praying all day, every day, trying to make it through this election and make sure our team is successful.”

He added that prayer “does work.” “You’ve just got to stay at it every day and build a closer relationship with our Savior,” Boehner said.

Immediately following the House takeover, when asked by ABC’s Diane Sawyer what role Catholicism plays in his life, the presumptive speaker said: “Well, it’s given me a real foundation of faith. And — while I don’t wear it on my shirtsleeve — I have deep abiding faith in Our Lord.”

And in his letter to House Republican members and members-elect two days after the election, Boehner paid tribute to his parents for sending him and his siblings to Catholic schools: “I grew up in a small house on a hill in Reading, Ohio, with 11 brothers and sisters. My dad owned a bar — Andy’s Café — that my grandfather Andy Boehner started in 1938. What little money my parents had they used to send all of us to Catholic schools. I worked nights as a janitor to put myself through college.”

Boehner, a Republican congressman from Ohio who is currently serving his 10th term in the House, has made his pro-life views a fundamental part of his tenure and campaign for the Republican House leadership and now the speakership. In the first of a series of speeches introducing himself as a national leader, Boehner spoke to the National Right to Life Committee in June.

Receiving the Defender of Life award from the group, Boehner said, “Respect for life has never been a political position for me. It just came naturally. It’s me. It’s what I believe. It’s what my parents instilled in me as I grew up in America. I think millions of Americans had a similar experience.”

He went on to say that “Americans love life, and we love freedom. They’re both intertwined, permanently, as part of the American character. America is a nation built on freedom. And without respect for life, freedom is in jeopardy.”

“When human life takes a back seat to other priorities — personal comforts, economics — freedom is diminished. By contrast, when we affirm the dignity of life, we affirm our commitment to freedom,” Boehner said.

On the health-care legislation, he pointed out that:

The overwhelming opposition of the American people to taxpayer funding of abortion almost kept it from becoming law.

The American people — and a bipartisan majority in the House — supported the Stupak amendment, which would have prohibited taxpayer funding of abortion through the health-care bill.

This presented a huge problem for President Obama and the Democratic leadership. Because the health-care overhaul wasn’t being driven by the will of the people; it was being driven by the will of special interests — radical special interests who believe the killing of unborn human life is “health care.”

Ultimately it became apparent to the White House and Democratic leaders that they couldn’t find the votes to kill the pro-life Stupak amendment. So they came up with a little maneuver.

Instead of heeding the will of the people and a bipartisan majority in the House, they crafted a disingenuous, last-minute executive order that they claimed eliminated the need for pro-life protections. The president issued the order, and White House aides indicated its enforcement would be a priority.

That, sadly, was good enough for a handful of legislators, including Rep. Stupak himself, who prior to that point had mounted a courageous fight.

But pro-life America didn’t buy it. They doubted the administration’s sincerity — and with good reason.

In the months following the passage of Obamacare, Boehner has consistently insisted that the administration provide progress reports on just how that executive order has been implemented, often to non-responses from the Department of Health and Human Services and the president himself.

When, in July, it was revealed that abortion funding was not, in fact, anathema to some states’ high-risk pools, Boehner increased the pressure on the administration, forcing the Department of Health and Human Services to issue a further regulation to safeguard taxpayer consciences from complicity in abortion funding.

During his National Right to Life Committee speech, Boehner said about abortion funding: “It’s time for Washington to stop defying the will of the American people on this critical, commonsense issue.”

Post-game analysts are insisting that the social issues weren’t issues this cycle, but the House Republican Pledge to America included plans to pass a permanent, universal Hyde Amendment, no small thing, in part in reaction to the promises made during the debate over abortion and health-care funding. In the months before the health-care legislation was passed, politicians who support legal abortion insisted that the Hyde Amendment already existed to protect against any kind of abortion funding. Not so, though. The Hyde Amendment, named after the late Henry Hyde, a Republican congressman from Illinois, only prohibits funding in one particular appropriations bill, which is subject to an annual fight. This pledge item would change that.

In his new book, Beyond a House Divided: The Moral Consensus Ignored by Washington, Wall Street, and the Media, Carl Anderson, supreme knight of the Knights of Columbus, argues that there is “enormous consensus” on the issue of abortion. Surveys done for the Knights by the Marist Poll found that eight out of 10 Americans “favor restrictions that would limit abortion to the first three months of pregnancy at most.” Additionally, underscoring the dynamic we saw this cycle with unprecedented number of pro-life women running for office, Anderson notes that “53 percent of Americans would limit abortion to cases of rape, incest, or to save the life of a mother — or would not allow it at all. Among women, the number is even higher — 55 percent.”

“People of faith turned out in the highest numbers in a midterm election we have ever seen, and they made an invaluable contribution to the historic results, including the election of a Republican majority in the House and significant gains in U.S. Senate seats, governorships, and hundreds of state legislative seats and local offices,” Ralph Reed, founder and chairman of the Faith and Freedom Coalition, pointed out the morning after Election Day. From a survey the Faith and Freedom Coalition commissioned, he highlighted “a 21-point advantage for GOP candidates for being pro-life and a 27-point advantage among white evangelicals versus all other white voters.”

That suggests that House Republicans are not just on the right track morally, but politically. Some House Democrats just learned that the hard way.

Kathryn Jean Lopez is editor-at-large of National Review Online and a nationally syndicated columnist. She can be reached at klopez@nationalreview.com.

 

 

 

Filed under catholic faith, catholic vote, catholic voters, catholicism, prayer, pro-life, u.s., u.s. congress, u.s. politics, vote

Comments

Post a Comment

I’m a pro-life Democrat. Abortion isn’t the only issue facing America. While Jesus never said anything about abortion, he spoke often and forcefully about caring for the sick and the poor. Pelossi and the Democrats, with the Health Care Law and other acts of Congress, have worked toward those ends. I would feel more comfortable with Boehner if he consistently voted his principles when it came to caring for the sick and the poor and not the wealthy and the insurance companies.

Praise the Lord Pelosi is out.  Only God knows the further damage she (and her ilk) could have done in the next 2 years.  Unfortunately, the news today said she still plans to run for House Minority Leader.  As for myself, I will gladly support any Christ centered Evangelical or Protestant before any Catholic (in name only) liberal.  John Boehner needs our prayers and support for the task ahead of him and Nancy Pelosi needs to go and hide herself back in San Francisco with her “Catholic???” friends Governor Elect Jerry Brown and Lt. Governor Elect Gavin Newsome who both support gay marriage.  They are disgusting.

Should we not identify Speaker Pelosi as a purported catholic because she most clearly does believe and support abortion (the murder of the yet to be born)?  In Columbus, Ohio, Representative Mary Jo Kilroy, a purported catholic, was also defeated by Republican Steve Stivers.  Nothing upsets me more than these purported catholics who believe in and support abortion.

How can John Boehner take Pelosi’s gavel if he is in the House?  Pelosi is in the Senate.

Nancy Pelosi is included in this quote, “But on that day, they will come to me and say, ‘Lord, Lord, we preached in your Name.  We healed in your Name.’  And I will say to them, ‘Depart from Me, you doers of iniquity.  I NEVER KNEW YOU.’”


So Nancy Pelosi can call herself whatever her little heart desires.  But it is our OBEDIENCE to God and to His Word that counts.  She has no exuse either.  Her shepherd in San Francisco, Archbishop George Niederauer, took the time to write to her two years ago, offering to personally meet with her, to instruct her about what it is to be a “Catholic”.  She never took him up on it, to my knowledge.


Nancy Pelosi is not Catholic.  She isn’t even Christian.  If she thinks she knows God, but does not know Him from His Word, the god she claims she knows is in her own imagination.  That will not cut it either here, or in the next life.


So if she doesn’t ever learn to live God’s way now - I hope she has a super life here, because in the next life, she’ll not be as comfortable.
God exists and His Word tells us He is “not mocked.”

Nancy Pelosi is a complete and utter disgrace.  Thanks for this hopeful and informative article.  Hopefully, our new speaker realizes that no country that murders its own children has any future.  All the pro-life candidates elected last week need to wake this troubled country from the pro-abortion nightmare that Obama and Pelosi et al plunged us into.

I pray that Mr. Boehner is more true to his faith than Ms. Pelosi has been She, and many countefeit Catholics in the Obama administration need to examine their consciences and do much, much penance.

Nancy Pelosi, an ardent practicing Catholyc!

It’s as I’ve been saying since 1980, I didn’t leave the democratic party, the democratic party left me with their far left agenda and pro-abortion platform and the contrast between Pelosi and Boehner say’s it all.

First we found out Dan Benishek replaced Stupak. (And there was great rejoicing.)  Then that Boehner replaced Pelosi. (And there was even more great rejoicing.)

But I have to admit, I will miss all the great Pelosi jokes!

This is a great article.  I didn’t know that about Boehner.  Sounds like he is made for the job.  Let’s pray for him that he doesn’t cave in like Stupak and most of the Democrats.  Ponnuru’s book “The Culture of Death” gives a very thorough account of all the political figures of the past and how so many of them all turned around when the chips were down and sold their integrity for 30 pieces of silver. 

The fact that Boehner came from a family of 11 children shows how families lay out the foundation of the value of Life.  His parents should reap a great reward for their sacrifices in having a large family. I am sure they are very proud of his accomplishments.

Again thank you for this wonderful news.  What a pleasant change has been affected in our land!!

Let’s hope the new team keeps the issue to the forefront so that young women (and men) take deep thought about the realities of abortion, because even if abortion is legal, it is a CHOICE - you don’t have to do it, you can choose to have your child. I personally feel that legislative initiatives are the least efficient means of getting real results, i.e. saving babies definitely now as opposed to maybe saving babies in some future realm. Conversion to a pro-life, pro-baby viewpoint among the childbearing and about-to-be childbearing segments of the population is a much more long-term solution than changing a law which can be changed back with equal and opposite effort,

Kathryn,
Seriously, do you think Roe vs. Wade is going away?  It is absurd that both sides expend so much energy on “social” issues!  Whichever side you sit on, the issue has been decided.  If abortion is outlawed we will go back to folks performing them illegally to no one’s satisfaction.
Balance the budget, stop the spending, end entitlement, get term limits for our lifetime politicians, get rid of onerous licensing and regulations that stifle new business and have government build roads and provide defense.

I don’t care how much Pelosi claims to be catholic. She is not catholic and in this I mean she has convicted herself by her own words. In the book she wrote she spoke of how she couldn’t believe that her granddaughter bought into the myth of Christ’s true presence in the Eucharist. If she doesn’t believe then she isn’t truly Catholic. What the government has done will not fix the healthcare problem but make it worse. How can abortion and artificial contrception be healthcare when they increase a woman’s chances of breast cancer? Not just any breast cancer but the most aggressive forms. Yes healthcare needs overhauled but the government taking over is not the answer.

Boehner “believes” Washington is defying the will of the people regarding it’s pro-abortion stance? Out here in flyover country, we’re way way beyond believing ; we know unmistakably.—————-And let’s remember that Christians, both Protestant and Catholic, oppose the infanticidal direction of this current Administration, its leader and his party.—————By the way: I still cannot reconcile how anyone calling himself or herself a Christian can say they’re a pro-life Democrat. The Bible speaks to taking on others’ sin—and this is one irrefutable example of people rationalizing away what they know in their heart is wrong and despicable.—————Choose life.

I don’t know much about the personal life of Rep. Boehner, but no way would I call the current and so to be former Speaker of the House anything but a “cultural” Catholic.  She kept the “fancy stuff for show” but was an otherwise empty vessel.  Worse than the “cafeteria” that mostly do keep up on some of the teachings, and are mostly “faithful,” Madame Speaker had less knowledge of the doctrines of her faith, than some of the children i helped to prepare for their First Communion or the Teens getting ready for Confirmation.

Imagine what the headlines would’ve been if Mrs. Pelosi (and other high profile Democrats) had been voted out…

Posted by Bob on Saturday, Nov 6, 2010 8:23 AM (EDT):How can John Boehner take Pelosi’s gavel if he is in the House?  Pelosi is in the Senate.


No, Bob, Nancy Pelosi is Speaker of the House. (But not for long!)

I was going to write something sarcastic about Pelosi, but I changed my mind.  I thought that she is a sister in to us Catholics in Christ Jesus. If our sister is leading a life not in union with the rest of the family we must let her know what she is doing wrong. First and foremost we must do it in love.  So I say, Nancy come home.  Come back to the family of God and live as a child of God.  We are not whole when one of our members is away from us.  Come home, we miss you.

Paul O’Pinion either does not understand what Roe v Wade refers to, or subscribes to it. How sad!

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.