Print Article | Email Article | Write To Us

The Smiting Is Still Implied

Thursday, February 11, 2010 2:15 PM Comments (4)

People have strange notions of God.  A semi-agnostic co-worker recently remarked to me that he regards the Bible as so much hooey because the God of the Old Testament is mean and wrathful while the God of the New Testament is about love and forgiveness.  How can Christians, he wondered, be silly enough to believe in both.  It seems to me that many people, whether or not they would articulate it in such a way, view God in much the same way.

They think that the God of the Old Testament created the world and was determined to run things His way.  Step out of line and He would send a flood or drop some fire and brimstone on you just as soon as look at you.  Follow the rules or He would open a whole can of smite on you.

The God of the New Testament, however, loves everyone just as they are.  He is all peace, love, and acceptance.  His suggestions on how to be “good” are merely that, suggestions.  Good ideas and all, but it really doesn’t matter at the end of the day, ‘cause we cool.

Of course, we know, that the God of the Old Testament is the same God of the New Testament.  God doesn’t change.  That goes with the whole eternal thing.

I was reminded of this by a child who lives around the corner who plays at my house from time to time.  He is a nice enough kid but completely undisciplined. This kid could jump up and down on the roof of a neighbor’s new Mercedes and his parents’ voices would probably never rise above the tone of polite conversation.  “Billy, get down from there,” they would likely say as the dings and dents accumulated.  Then, after a try or two, throw up their hands in frustration and say, “That Billy sure is a handful.  Do you want some more iced tea?”

Billy views his parents like the New Testament God.  Billy expects them to take care of him, feed him, and clothe him, but any other instruction is most likely to be ignored with little or no consequence anticipated.

I am, on the other hand, like the Old Testament God and my children and Billy know it.  My instructions are to be followed or there will be smiting.  Billy was playing at my house some weeks ago and I spied him and my son doing something dangerous with a tree branch. I instructed them to stop.  My son stopped but Billy continued.  I told him again and he abruptly turned around and yelled at me, “I will do what I want, leave me alone!”.

I strolled up to Billy and stood right in front of him.  I leaned down and in a very soft voice said, “When you are over my house, young man, you will obey my rules and rule #1 is that you do not speak to adults that way.  Ever.  Rule #2 is that if I tell you to stop doing something, you stop doing it.  Immediately.  If you do not wish to obey these rules then you are not allowed to play here anymore and I will call your parents and tell them so.  Do you understand?”.

Billy, eyes wide and mouth open, simply nodded.  Billy has been back several times since then without incident.

Don’t I love my children just as much as Billy’s parents love him?  Of course I do.  As my children mature they have begun to understand that my love, tenderness, and affection for them comes from the same place as does my discipline.  And also as they mature I expect different things from them.  Further, with my older children I take the time to explain why I sometimes say no, more than I would with my younger children.  They can understand more and so I share more. I am the same Daddy, they just understand me differently.

And so it is with God.  His love for us is eternal and unchanging.  It is our understanding, as individuals and as a people, that changes.

This is important to remember as we recall what Jesus said to the adulterous woman after saving her from stoning.  “Go and sin no more.”. And so, as I am sometimes tempted to choose not to listen to this admonition of the New Testament God, I do well to remember one thing.  The smiting is still implied.

 

Filed under

Comments

Post a Comment

Thanks, Pat, for the article. Having recently converted to Catholicism, my appreciation is for the both/and, not the either/or. Yes, God is amazingly loving, beyond anything I imagine. Yes, God created the world, and this is basically His call. You can choose to do whatever you like and assume that He doesn’t care or will “let it slide”, but your assumption will land your soul in great peril. The love of Christ constrains us, making it possible for us to go and sin no more. Now that is a faith worth living.

It doesn’t change the fact that the God of the OT commands rape victims to marry their rapists.  [Deut 22:28]  That goes a bit beyond some sort of “deserved smiting” or deserved stoning-to-death, don’t you think?

It doesn’t change the fact that the God of the OT commands rape victims to marry their rapists.  [Deut 22:28]

Actually, it commands the rapist to marry the victim—an important distinction.  And an excellent example of the author’s point.  For without that marriage, said rape victim at that time would likely be doomed to a life of ostracism, prostitution, slavery, or perhaps even become the victim of an honor killing.  By marrying her, this aspect of the Law ensured her protection and survival.  Harsh by today’s standards, certainly, but a “tough love” improvement over the only alternative at that time.

A common conundrum nicely elucidated. I’m just worried that, while you’re here perfecting your apologetics, Billy is in his basement plotting his revenge :-o

Post a Comment

By submitting this form, you give The National Catholic Register permission to publish this comment. Comments will be published at our discretion, and may be edited for clarity and length. For best formatting, please limit your response to one paragraph and don't hit "enter" to force line breaks.

Name:

Email:

Write your comment:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

     

Notify me of follow-up comments.

About Pat Archbold

Pat Archbold
  • Get the RSS feed
Patrick Archbold is co-founder of Creative Minority Report, a Catholic website that puts a refreshing spin on the intersection of religion, culture, and politics. When not writing, Patrick is director of information technology at a large international logistics company. Patrick, his wife Terri, and their five children reside in Long Island, N.Y.