Conversation with a Good-Natured and Confused Person

04/25/2012 Comments (28)

He wrote:

I take the story of Jesus metaphorically too, like many biblical stories in the old testament. I take it as a story that wants to give us a theological message, which in the end is the important thing, wheter or not it happened.

The people who report the story, and who died for it in gruesome ways, neglected to make this clear to the people who crucified them, stabbed them, and stoned them to death. The key to understanding a text is not to ask, “What does it mean to me?” but “What did it mean to the people who wrote it?” Those people very obviously meant to say that they had seen Jesus Christ alive bodily after his death and had eaten fish with him and poked their...READ MORE

Filed under mailbag

Question about the HHS Mandate Snow Job

04/23/2012 Comments (54)

A reader writes:

I'd love to see you discuss the following on your blog: in the rhetoric of those pushing for forced contraception provision in health-insurance plans, there seems to be an implicit "fatalistic adversarialism" (to coin a phrase). When you listen to the contraception party's statements, they seem to claim "Women are being restricted from obtaining contraception by this or that employer." What's inherent in such statements is (a) an assumption that a woman employee has no where else to go for employment, that some how she is stuck with the offending employer (this is the "fatalistic" portion); and (b) an assumption that the employer, simply by not providing something...READ MORE

Filed under

Certain Inconsistencies That Chesterton Would have Loved

04/19/2012 Comments (35)

My atheist friend, back for more, writes:

Atheists don't crib from "Judeo-Christian morality" but try to follow the Golden Rule, something that existed in human thought and morality long, long before Jesus or even the Hebrews and is taught by all religions and philosophies in one form or another.

My reader is apparently unaware that there is a distinction between the Golden Rule ("Do unto others as you would have them do unto you') and various forms of natural law which prescribe a sort of rough and ready sociableness that can vary widely from culture to culture.  It is simply not the case that all cultures "basically say the same thing" and it is emphatically not the case that...READ MORE

Filed under

A reader has a question about a fundamentalist theory about hell

04/17/2012 Comments (97)

She writes:

I work out of Shreveport, Louisiana, just right along the Bible belt, where Catholics are a minority among the Christian community. In my workplace, it is clear that I am Catholic (saints calendar, purgatory book, and a rosary right on my desk). It's my mini way of evangelizing due to the fact that God did not gift me with an eloquent tongue on fire.

I had a Baptist coworker (we talk a lot on theology and prayer openly at work) who came up to me today apologizing for his disregard in helping me at work yesterday. I told him to think nothing of it, which turned into a friendly conversation about what we did after work. I told him, since I don't have internet at home...READ MORE

Filed under

Scratch an Atheist, Find a Fundamentalist

04/15/2012 Comments (143)


So the other day, on my Patheos blog, I note that poor Cardinal Pell made the cardinal (get it?) mistake of forgetting that the purpose of the MSM is not to inform or enlighten, but to sell beer and shampoo by ginning up hysteria and fake dudgeon about idiotic nonsense.  Case in point:

Step 1: Arrange a debate between Richard Dawkins and Leading Catholic Prelate.

Step 2: Allow Dawkins to blather about how Old Testament Jews were a small tribe of ignorant savages and brutal barbarians who were way behind us in their understanding of 21st century moral standards, not to mention in their grasp of biology and the art of making blenders and microwaves.  This is, of course,...READ MORE

Filed under

In the Country that Used to be England

04/12/2012 Comments (87) has long been a given that all religions are equally superior to the Catholic Church.  Now that the country has largely de-Christianized, that has expanded to the confidence that all religions are equally superior to Christianity.  So, for instance, Cameron's Britain takes it for granted that Christians can not only be compelled not to wear crosses, but that if one of them becomes uppity enough to do so, all you have to do is trot out the language about mean Christians who advertise their faith as though it was superior to other beliefs.  Whipped Christians, timid about appearing "judgmental", often capitulate to this sort of draconian post-Christian appeal to "judge not, lest ye be...READ MORE

Filed under

I stand corrected

04/11/2012 Comments (6)

In response to this recent piece, in which I remarked that it seems to me wrong-headed to use the story of Onan in Genesis 38 as a “proof text” against contraception reader Pete Holter writes:

You are making the care of widows the focus of Genesis 38 by saying that “children were the sole ‘social safety net’ that widows had,” and you come back to this main point in your response to George; but the care of widows is something separate from situations involving heirs and inheritance rights.  When these latter types of situations arise, the Biblical texts explicitly state that providing offspring and preserving property is done, not for the sake of the widow, but for the sake of the...READ MORE

Filed under mailbag

God's Laughter Day

04/09/2012 Comments (21)

In many places, the Monday of Easter week is the day for celebrating God’s laughter.  Easter, after all, is not just our deliverance from death, but the ultimate instance of God, in a sort of zen humility, quietly putting one over on the devil.  On Calvary, God gave the mighty Lucifer—that great jackass—all the rope he needed to hang himself.  On Easter Monday, the Church shouts (in proper ecclesial Latin), “What a maroon!  What a sucker!  Good job genius!  You had it all figured out, you great bullying murderer and tyrant.  You finally got the plum prize in your claws and figured you’d won once and for all.  You nailed him to the cross, and now you and your kingdom of death are hurled to...READ MORE

Filed under happy easter

Page 45 of 87 pages ‹ First  < 43 44 45 46 47 >  Last ›

About Mark Shea

Mark Shea
  • Get the RSS feed
Mark P. Shea is a popular Catholic writer and speaker. The author of numerous books, his most recent work is The Work of Mercy (Servant) and The Heart of Catholic Prayer (Our Sunday Visitor). Mark contributes numerous articles to many magazines, including his popular column “Connecting the Dots” for the National Catholic Register. Mark is known nationally for his one minute “Words of Encouragement” on Catholic radio. He also maintains the Catholic and Enjoying It blog. He lives in Washington state with his wife, Janet, and their four sons.